Madoff Investors' Group Questions Clawback Suits

Dec 8 2010 | 5:17pm ET

The Network for Investor Action and Protection, a group set up to assist victims of Bernard Madoff’s Ponzi scheme, is questioning some of the latest suits filed by the trustee overseeing the liquidation of Madoff’s investment business.

NIAP President Ron Stein has written the Securities Investor Protection Corporation and Iriving Picard, the trustee in question, to explain why “innocent” investors are being targeted with clawback actions.

Picard has filed hundreds of suits in recent weeks, many of them against what he has termed the “net winners” in the Ponzi scheme i.e. investors who withdrew more than they invested. Picard doesn’t claim these investors knew about the fraud, simply that they should return their profits to help reduce the losses of other victims.

Picard has approved 15,491 investor claims for a total of $5.8 billion. The lawsuits filed to date are for more than $32 billion. Stein wants to know what will be done with money over and above the $5.8 billion needed by the SIPC to satisfy claims.

“The Trustee has said he must sue investors to recover monies to give to so-called net losers,” said Stein. “Having already sued guilty parties for over $32 billion to cover only $5.8 billion in claims, why is it necessary to also sue innocent people, who often are aged, many who are suffering tremendous economic stress and emotional distress, and cannot even afford lawyers?”

Picard’s findings suggest the total lost to Madoff’s scheme was just under $20 billion. Picard’s law firm has said any funds recovered by the trustee will be distributed to investors based on the size of their claims. Next, the trustee will settle the $1.7 billion owed to non-investor creditors (including $250 million in fees to the SIPC, which has paid to retain Picard and other professionals trying to recover investor money).

It has been suggested that anything left over could be distributed to Madoff investors as profit, but SIPC President Stephen Harbeck told Time magazine this week that the chances of Picard recovering that much money were slim.

"There is a big difference between filing a suit, winning a suit and being able to collect on that suit," said Harbeck.


In Depth

GSAM's Papagiannis: Liquid Alternatives For The Long Run

Apr 21 2017 | 8:44pm ET

Interest in liquid alternatives cooled a bit last year amid a broad shift in investor...

Lifestyle

Aston Martin Returns To Debt Market As DB11 Drives Turnaround

Mar 31 2017 | 5:21pm ET

James Bond’s preferred carmaker is returning to the public debt markets for the...

Guest Contributor

Debunking Conventional Investment Wisdom (Part II)

Apr 17 2017 | 5:56pm ET

The alternative investment industry is currently replete with buzzwords around data...

 

From the current issue of