Prosecutors Call Goffer Evidence 'Overwhelming,' Defense Calls It 'Ridiculous'

Jun 2 2011 | 3:28pm ET

Prosecutors called their evidence in the second Galleon Group insider-trading trial "overwhelming," urging jurors in their closing statement to convict Zvi Goffer, Emanuel Goffer and Michael Kimelman.

Assistant U.S. Attorney Richard Tarlowe, telling the panel that they "heard the defendant's own voice," again played for the jury several of the "devastating calls" at the heart of the case.

Tarlowe also hammered home the government's contention that Goffer, the alleged leader of the insider-trading ring, did all he could to cover up his actions and those of his co-conspirators, erecting a "smokescreen."

"Why do you conceal what you're doing?" Tarlowe asked of defendant Goffer's use of prepaid cellular phones. "You conceal because you know what you're doing is wrong, and you don't want to get caught."

Emanuel Goffer's lawyer mocked the government's reliance on the prepaid cell phones.

"This case seems like U.S. vs. prepaid phones," Michael Ross complained.

Zvi Goffer's lawyer also dismissed the allegations.

"God forbid somebody finds themselves in the cross-hairs of the federal government," William Barzee told the jury. "They take absolutely innocent facts" and "they twist it to fit their story." Barzee called his client a "habitual exaggerator" who was faking things.

"He wants to pretend he has inside information, he has an edge," Barzee said. Another lawyer for Zvi Goffer, David Pettus, went further.

"He wanted David Slaine's money" when he claimed to have confidential information, Pettus said, referring to one of the prosecution's key witnesses. "He said some really stupid things."

And if he did have word of a deal before its public announcement, that hardly qualifies as insider-trading, according to Barzee.

"It's ridiculous," he said. "It's the real world. Things get out."


In Depth

Humble in Hofstra...One Debate an Election Can Make

Sep 26 2016 | 10:20am ET

Tonight's U.S. Presidential debate, infamously coined the “Humbling in Hofstra...

Lifestyle

Quattrex Sports AG Debuts Soccer-Focused UCITS Fund

Sep 9 2016 | 9:54pm ET

Innovative alternative investment company Quattrex Sports has unveiled a new UCITS...

Guest Contributor

Malik: The Ever-Changing Middle Market and The Entering Class of 2016

Sep 2 2016 | 5:01pm ET

Deal sourcing and origination is only going to get more competitive given current...