Monday, 26 September 2016
Last updated 44 min ago
Nov 2 2011 | 10:52am ET
Raj Rajaratnam has suffered enough—and isn't such a bad guy, despite his conviction on insider-trading charges.
That's the gist of the Galleon Group founder's argument as to why he should be spared paying more than $100 million in addition disgorgement and fines. Rajaratnam's lawyers told U.S. District Judge Jed Rakoff, overseeing the Securities and Exchange Commission's lawsuit against him, that the former hedge fund manager has "already suffered enormous financial consequences" as a result of his conviction. Those consequences, plus an 11-year prison term, are "sufficient" punishment for the crime, they said.
The SEC disagrees: It is seeking more than $41 million in disgorgement and prejudgment interest and fines of $94.7 million—figures that would probably be reduced by the $53.8 million in disgorgement and $10 million in fines Rajaratnam has already paid in the criminal case.
Rajaratnam's lawyers took issue with the SEC's math in determining those figures, but primarily urged that Rajaratnam's criminal sentence and his actions to protect client assets in the wake of his arrest be taken into account.
Rajaratnam's decision to quickly shutter Galleon and return money to investors after his 2009 arrest "show that he was not motivated by greed or by the desire to make a lot of money."