Madoff Trustee Loses In $20 Billion Bank Battle

Nov 2 2011 | 10:54am ET

A federal judge has dismissed two of the larger lawsuits filed by the court-appointed trustee in the Bernard Madoff case.

Irving Picard does not have the right to seek some $21 billion from JPMorgan Chase, Madoff's primary banker for decades, and UBS, U.S. District Judge Colleen McMahon ruled. The judge cited an earlier ruling, from July, dismissing a similar, $8.8 billion lawsuit against two other banks, HSBC and UniCredit.

Picard accused the two banks of turning a blind eye to Madoff's $65 billion Ponzi scheme, and argued that his lawsuit was the only practicable way for Madoff's victims to receive recompense from the banks.

McMahon did not disagree with that point, noting that "allowing the trustee to pursue claims that belong properly to individual creditors would accrue to the benefit of all creditors." But, "this theory is not supported by the statute's text and history or by any persuasive case law."

McMahon ruled, as her colleague U.S. District Judge Jed Rakoff did earlier, that when dealing with third parties, Picard represented Madoff, and not Madoff's victims. Only the fraudster's victims—his creditors—can sue third parties.

Picard can continue to pursue his actions against the two banks, but at a much-reduced level. He can only seek to recover the fictional profits withdrawn by the banks over a two-year period prior to Madoff's arrest in December 2008. That means JPMorgan is on the hook for less than $500 million, while UBS could face claims in excess of $1 billion.

Picard said he planned to appeal McMahon's ruling.


In Depth

bfinance: Fees Falling Across Asset Classes, Yet Overall Investor Costs Still Climbing

May 16 2017 | 9:53pm ET

Despite unprecedented attention on fees, new research from investment consultancy...

Lifestyle

CFA Institute To Add Computer Science To Exam Curriculum

May 24 2017 | 9:25pm ET

Starting in 2019, financial industry executives sitting for the coveted Chartered...

Guest Contributor

Risk-Based Compliance: Why Oversight Of Outsourcing Is Critical

May 10 2017 | 7:02pm ET

Compliance is notoriously one of the trickiest middle office functions for funds...

 

From the current issue of