All Clients Can Get Piece Of Lehman Pool, Court Rules

Mar 1 2012 | 12:00pm ET

The U.K.'s highest court has ruled that all Lehman Brothers clients can share in a pool of the bankrupt investment bank's segregated client assets, a victory for some hedge funds and a stinging defeat for others.

The U.K. Supreme Court ruled Lehman customers, including prime brokerage clients, can share in the US$2 billion pool, and not just those clients whose capital was properly segregated. Judge John Dyson wrote that "all client money is subject to a trust that arises upon receipt of the money by the firm," making it irrelevant whether Lehman properly ring-fenced a client's money or not.

Dyson admitted that, under his ruling, the Lehman collapse created a "cataclysmic shift of beneficial ownership." But all clients must equally share in the misfortune if the wrongdoing was the fault of the firm, he said.

The ruling is a major victory for hedge fund CRC Credit, as well as for Lehman's U.S. and Swiss businesses. On the other hand, it’s a tough defeat for GLG Partners, which argued the case of clients whose money was properly segregated, and the receiver for Lehman Brothers International (Europe), where the client money was actually housed.

GLG's lawyer, Jennifer Marshall, warned that the ruling would have a chilling effect on British investment firms and investors, citing one of the Supreme Court's dissenting judges. Judge Robert Walker wrote that the decision "makes investment banking more of a lottery than even its fiercest critics have supposed."


In Depth

GSAM's Papagiannis: Liquid Alternatives For The Long Run

Apr 21 2017 | 8:44pm ET

Interest in liquid alternatives cooled a bit last year amid a broad shift in investor...

Lifestyle

Aston Martin Returns To Debt Market As DB11 Drives Turnaround

Mar 31 2017 | 5:21pm ET

James Bond’s preferred carmaker is returning to the public debt markets for the...

Guest Contributor

Debunking Conventional Investment Wisdom (Part II)

Apr 17 2017 | 5:56pm ET

The alternative investment industry is currently replete with buzzwords around data...

 

From the current issue of