Judge Refuses To Toss Madoff Trustee Suit Against Mets Owners

Mar 6 2012 | 2:32pm ET

U.S. District Judge Jed Rakoff refused to throw out a $386 lawsuit against the owners of the New York Mets by the trustee for Bernard Madoff’s investment firm.

While Rakoff owned he remained “skeptical” about Madoff Trustee Irving Picard’s ability to win the suit, he nevertheless on Monday rejected the bid by Fred Wilpon and Saul Katz to toss it out of court.

Picard claims Wilpon and Katz acted in bad faith dealing with Madoff, but the ball club owners say they saw nothing to raise red flags during the 20 years they entrusted their money with the convicted fraudster, who is currently serving a 150-year prison sentence.

The ruling may allow for an out-of-court settlement of the case, which is scheduled to go to trial March 19.

Picard spokeswoman Amanda Remus told Reuters the trustee was reviewing the decision.

Rakoff said Picard could potentially recover the profits made by the Mets owners in the two years prior to the 2008 bankruptcy of Bernard L. Madoff Investment Securities. That sum, he said, would be determined later but could total as much as $83.3 million. However, he said Picard would have his work cut out for him proving the owners acted in bad faith during that period.

Rakoff also warned that much of the “evidence” offered on both sides would not be admissible.

"Conclusions are no substitute for facts, and too much of what the parties characterized as bombshells proved to be nothing but bombast," Rakoff wrote. "Nevertheless, there remains a residue of disputed factual assertions from which a jury could infer either good or bad faith."

Rakoff has already trimmed Picard’s demands considerably—last September he threw out more than half of the original $1 billion lawsuit.

In Depth

Related-Company Fees: Normal Industry Practice or Conflicted Compensation?

Nov 11 2015 | 4:23pm ET

Regulatory agencies as well as investors are increasingly exploring whether certain...


Ferrari Roars in Wall Street Debut

Oct 21 2015 | 4:28pm ET

Shares of supercar maker Ferrari jumped as much as 15 percent to a high of nearly...

Guest Contributor

Private Debt - What is the Opportunity?

Nov 11 2015 | 3:28pm ET

In this contributed article, Rob Allard, founding partner of Firebreak Capital...


Editor's Note

    Oct 21 2015 | 10:41am ET

    One of the most unique charity benefits in the hedge fund industry, A Leg To Stand On's (ALTSO's) Hedge Fund Rocktoberfest - NYC, raised nearly $500,000 last Thursday thanks to the generous support of major sponsors and nearly 1,400 attendees from the Tri-State finance, business and hedge fund communities. Read more…