Court: Compliance Officer Can't Sue Over Firing

May 9 2012 | 9:29am ET

New York State's highest court has ruled that Peconic Partners' former chief compliance officer can't sue the hedge fund for firing him—even though he alleges he was fired for confronting the firm's CEO about the latter's allegedly illegal trading.

The Court of Appeals ruled yesterday that to allow Joseph Sullivan to sue for wrongful termination would make New York law "more intrusive" than federal law, something the court was unwilling to do. So it rejected Sullivan's appeal of a lower court decision to toss the lawsuit.

"Nothing in federal law persuades us that we should change our own law to create a remedy where Congress did not," the ruling, approved by five of the seven judges on the appeals panel, wrote.

Sullivan claims he was fired after questioning CEO William Harnish's trading. Sullivan alleges that Harnish engaged in front-running of Potash Corp. shares, selling his own stake in the fertilizer company day before dumping the hedge fund's stake for much less.

Sullivan's claims for breach-of-contract and defamation remain active, as is Peconic's countersuit against Sullivan.

Despite Sullivan's lawyer's argument that his client was "fired for doing the job he was hired to do," the Court of Appeals noted that he was not just its compliance chief, but held four other titles. In addition, it ruled that he was not covered by laws protecting whistleblowers, since he had confronted Harnish directly about the alleged front-running, rather than bringing it to the proper authorities.

"We are delighted with the court of appeals’ decision to affirm the unanimous decision of the Appellate Division and to put an end to Mr. Sullivan’s smear campaign against his former employer,” David Scharf, the Peconic CEO's lawyer, said. “Mr. Sullivan’s claims are entirely baseless."

The decision was not without controversy. Two judges dissented, with one, the court's chief judge, Jonathan Lippman, writing that ruling "an investment adviser like Peconic has every right to fire its compliance officer, simply for doing his job, flies in the face of what we have learned from the Madoff debacle, runs counter to the letter and spirit of this Court's precedent, and facilitates the perpetration of frauds on the public."

For his part, Sullivan's lawyer, David Felber, said he would lobby the state legislature to provide protections for compliance officers like his client.


In Depth

Part II: Roubini Talks Risk, Recovery And The Threat Of A Triple Dip Recession

Oct 21 2014 | 12:41pm ET

In the second half of our interview with Nouriel Roubini, FINalternatives editor...

Lifestyle

Balyasny Pays Over $6M For Lakefront House

Oct 22 2014 | 10:29am ET

A venture headed by hedge fund manager Dmitry Balyasny just paid $6.2 million for...

Guest Contributor

Hedge Funds Weather A Data Management Perfect Storm

Oct 22 2014 | 12:28pm ET

From a regulatory standpoint, nearly every development since the crisis has placed...

 

Videos

Editor's Note

    Guidelines for Guest Articles

    Oct 22 2014 | 9:46am ET

    We are always looking for guest articles from hedge fund managers and buy-side firms.

    If you are interested in submitting a contributed piece for possible publication on FINalternatives, please take a look at the specs. Read more…

 

Futures Magazine

October 2014 Cover

Deeply flawed risk benchmark

Most traders agree that proper risk management is the key to successful trading. However, many traders depend on the deeply flawed measure of standard deviation as a benchmark of risk. Here we put it ...

The Alpha Pages

TAP July/August 2014 Cover

The Alpha Pages Interview: Senator Rand Paul

Senator Paul sat down in the debut series of the Alpha Pages Interview to discuss the broken tax code, regulation surrounding Bitcoin, and his plans for the 2016 Presidential election.