Thursday, 27 April 2017
Last updated 4 hours ago
Mar 15 2013 | 12:40am ET
Pershing Square Capital Management founder William Ackman and nutritional supplements company Herbalife are back at each other's throats.
The activist hedge fund manager offered a new presentation attacking Herbalife, four months after first calling the company a pyramid scheme. Herbalife dismissed it as a demonstration of "Ackman's level of desperation."
Ackman's presentation, released on his Web site factsaboutherbalife.com, compares the direct-selling company to Fortune Hi-Tech Marketing. For Pershing Square, which has a $1 billion short bet against Herbalife, the comparison is fortuitous: Fortune Hi-Tech was charged with running a pyramid scheme by the Federal Trade Commission earlier this year.
Ackman has called on the FTC to investigate Herbalife's practices.
The slides compared the two companies' mission statements, compensation structures and income claims. Pershing Square released them in a week that has already seen a prominent consumer group call for an FTC probe into Herbalife and a class-action lawsuit filed against Ackman nemesis Carl Icahn, a major Herbalife investor, and Herbalife's banks, accusing them of complicity in Herbalife's alleged fraud.
Herbalife shot back that the presentation was merely about "generating headlines."
"It demonstrates Bill Ackman’s level of desperation with regard to his reckless $1 billion bet," Los Angeles-based Herbalife said. "The primary sourcing for this most recent report is Ackman’s own December 20 presentation, which itself is based on misrepresentations and factual inaccuracies. In the last three months, Bill Ackman has proven none of his claims about Herbalife and its business model."