Hedge Fund Can't Force Arbitration In MBS Dispute

May 20 2013 | 12:17pm ET

If Turnberry Capital Management wants its $13 million back from SunTrust Banks, it will have to seek it in the courts.

A federal judge in New York sided with SunTrust on Friday, blocking the hedge fund's arbitration claim against the bank. Turnberry, which went under in 2008, is seeking $13 million it lost on mortgage-backed securities issued by SunTrust the year before.

Turnberry wanted the case heard by a Financial Industry Regulatory Authority arbitration panel. But U.S. District Judge Naomi Reice Buchwald ruled that the hedge fund doesn't qualify as a SunTrust customer under FINRA rules.

Instead, it was Raymond James Financial, from which Turnberry bought the securities, that is the customer, as Turnberry "did not receive any other goods or services from SunTrust that would indicate a customer relationship." Turnberry had argued that the "economic reality" was the Raymond James was a mere conduit for selling the MBS.


In Depth

Dillon Eustace: The Advantages of ICAVs

Feb 11 2016 | 7:51pm ET

As the growth of alternative investment vehicles continues, global asset managers...

Lifestyle

Citadel's Ken Griffin Donates $40M To New York's Museum of Modern Art

Dec 22 2015 | 9:23pm ET

Citadel founder Ken Griffin has donated $40 million to New York’s Museum of Modern...

Guest Contributor

Hedging Against Reputational Risk in the 21st Century

Feb 12 2016 | 7:18pm ET

For investors, the first step in researching a new fund or manager is to google...