Sunday, 25 September 2016
Last updated 2 days ago
Jul 25 2013 | 10:32am ET
Morgan Stanley will not have to defend itself against an energy hedge fund's breach of contract claim, a federal judge has again ruled.
U.S. District Judge Andrew Carter in March dismissed most of Peak Ridge Commodities Volatility Fund's countersuit against the bank, which alleged that Morgan Stanley violated its agreement with the hedge fund when it seized a Peak Ridge natural-gas account after the hedge fund missed a margin call. The hedge fund asked Carter to reconsider, pointing to a phone call in which a Morgan Stanley representative said it would have more time to comply with the higher margin requirement.
But Carter said he hadn't overlooked the phone call—he was just enforcing the part of the contract that required modifications to be written, rather than oral. And even if the representative's assurances were binding, they were irrelevant, coming as they did after the margin deadline passed.
Carter allowed one claim—that Morgan Stanley was guilty of a conflict of interest when it handed Peak Ridge's account for liquidation to a trader who was competing with the hedge fund—to stand. Peak Ridge alleges that the trader caused it losses of $32 million.
For its part, Morgan Stanley accuses Peak Ridge of saddling it with $40.6 million in losses.