MF Global Customer Lawsuit Stands—With A Scolding

Feb 12 2014 | 10:21am ET

U.S. District Judge Victor Marrero sounds as though he'd very much like to dismiss a lawsuit against former executives of the collapsed MF Global. But for the second time, he's refused to do so.

Marrero said yesterday that it was reasonable to infer that someone "did something wrong to set in motion such an extraordinary chain of events causing such extensive harm to so many people and interests." But he also blasted the customer lawsuit as "wasteful and rancorous."

The judge dismissed some parts of the lawsuit, criticizing the customers' lawyers for asserting claims that "fly in the face of clear precedent." And, as if that wasn't enough, Marrero blasted both sides for not resolving the matter "in a just and efficient way."

In November, Marrero also refused to dismiss an investor lawsuit against former MF Global CEO Jon Corzine and other executives, similarly reasoning that someone was probably at fault for the "massive train wreck" that was MF Global's failure. And last month, he allowed to stand a Commodity Futures Trading Commission lawsuit against Corzine and former MF Global assistant treasurer Edith O'Brien.

In the customer lawsuit, Marrero dismissed claims that Corzine and O'Brien directly violated the Commodity Exchange Act, but allowed claims that he aided and abetted the violation of the law to proceed. He also threw out the case against auditor PricewaterhouseCoopers and some state-law claims. But the heart of the case—breach of fiduciary duty, negligence and tortious interference with contract and business advantage—remain.


In Depth

bfinance: Fees Falling Across Asset Classes, Yet Overall Investor Costs Still Climbing

May 16 2017 | 9:53pm ET

Despite unprecedented attention on fees, new research from investment consultancy...

Lifestyle

Aston Martin Returns To Debt Market As DB11 Drives Turnaround

Mar 31 2017 | 5:21pm ET

James Bond’s preferred carmaker is returning to the public debt markets for the...

Guest Contributor

Risk-Based Compliance: Why Oversight Of Outsourcing Is Critical

May 10 2017 | 7:02pm ET

Compliance is notoriously one of the trickiest middle office functions for funds...

 

From the current issue of