Judge Rules Accountants Not Liable In Hedge Fund Collapse

Jul 10 2008 | 2:01pm ET

Auditors are not liable for negligence where hedge fund managers exercise “nearly unfettered control” over a fund’s (fraudulent) activities, a New York judge has ruled.

New York Supreme Court Justice Charles Ramos granted a summary judgment motion to Ernst & Young, which was sued by the liquidators of a collapsed hedge fund E&Y audited. Ramos ruled that liquidators cannot bring claims against an auditor where the wrongdoing in a case “is imputable” to the fund itself.

The fund in question is Beacon Hill Asset Management, which collapsed in 2002. The Securities and Exchange Commission alleged the fund’s investment managers committed securities fraud leading to more than $300 million in losses, charges eventually settled. The liquidators of the Beacon Hill Master fund also accused the fund’s managers of fraudulently inflating the value of the mortgage-backed securities it owned, and also claimed that E&Y had failed to detect the wrongdoing in the first quarter of 2002 due to a deficient audit.

The “fundamental principle of agency that the wrongdoing of corporate management committed within the scope of their employment will generally be imputed to the corporation,” Ramos ruled.

“This decision is significant because it strengthens the state courts’ defenses available to auditors defending against claims of negligence by their former clients,” E&Y’s lawyer, Richard Martin, said.

The liquidators’ attorney, Scott Berman, rejected Ramos’ reasoning and said he has filed notice of appeal.

“The judge’s decision was contrary to other case law in New York and the trend nationwide,” he said.

The liquidators sued Beacon Hill’s managers, administrators, auditors and Beacon Hill Asset Management itself. All save E&Y has since settled the case.


In Depth

The Benefits Of Private Debt Investing

May 7 2015 | 10:43am ET

Jeffrey Haas is chief operating officer of Old Hill Partners Inc., an SEC-registered...

Lifestyle

Yale Receives $150 Million Gift from Blackstone’s Schwarzman

May 12 2015 | 12:10am ET

Yale University announced it has received a $150 million gift from Blackstone Group...

Guest Contributor

How To Generate 6% Yield In A Volatile World

May 22 2015 | 6:41am ET

Private credit comes in many different flavors, all with the common themes of over...

 

Sponsored Content

Editor's Note