Hedge Fund Decries CDS-Clearing ‘Oligopoly’

Jun 2 2009 | 1:12am ET

A hedge fund backer of the CME Group’s languishing credit-default swap clearinghouse has accused the banks supporting a rival CDS guarantor of torpedoing the CME’s plans.

Samuel Cole, chief operating officer of New York-based BlueMountain Capital Management, made the accusation in a letter to banks following a conference call last week of the International Swaps and Derivatives Association’s credit steering committee and buy-side clearing working group, Bloomberg News reports. BlueMountain is one of several hedge funds that are founding members of CME’s CMDX clearinghouse, which has yet to clear a single CDS.

“The dealers suggested more than once that there is room for only one solution in the market,” Cole wrote, referring to the Intercontinental Exchange’s ICE Trust, which is backed by such market heavyweights as Goldman Sachs and Morgan Stanley, and which has cleared some $710 billion in CDS since March. “The dealer community may be filibustering to protect its oligopoly and not seriously engaged in working with the buy side to develop a clearing solution.”

A copy of Cole’s letter was sent to Theo Lubke, who oversees over-the-counter derivatives trading at the New York Federal Reserve Bank.

“I would urge the dealers to change course and work with us to build a viable clearing solution that is in the interest of the entire market,” Cole wrote. And he also sought to head off charges of hypocrisy, as his own firm receives a fee discount from CMDX as a founding member.

“BlueMountain’s economic arrangement with CME is immaterial to its investors,” he wrote. “Dealers are deriving substantially more economic value from their relationshop with ICE than the six buy-side firms are from their relationship with CME.”


In Depth

Steinbrugge: Will Hedge Funds Help or Hurt During the Next Market Correction?

Sep 7 2016 | 11:55pm ET

Most investors have become accustomed to quick rebounds when markets correct, but...

Lifestyle

Quattrex Sports AG Debuts Soccer-Focused UCITS Fund

Sep 9 2016 | 9:54pm ET

Innovative alternative investment company Quattrex Sports has unveiled a new UCITS...

Guest Contributor

Malik: The Ever-Changing Middle Market and The Entering Class of 2016

Sep 2 2016 | 5:01pm ET

Deal sourcing and origination is only going to get more competitive given current...