Monday, 20 February 2017
Last updated 2 days ago
Oct 1 2009 | 3:14am ET
Philip Goldstein is well-known for speaking his mind. But a Massachusetts court has ruled against the Bulldog Investors chief in a free-speech case over who should have access to information about hedge funds.
Suffolk Superior Court Judge Judith Fabricant ruled that Secretary of the Commonwealth William Galvin did not violate Bulldog’s free-speech rights when he sued the hedge fund for marketing to an unqualified investor.
The court defeat for Goldstein, who successfully challenged the Securities and Exchange Commission’s hedge-fund registration requirement three years ago, comes in his ongoing battle with a man he has affectionately referred to as a “pompous ass.” Two years ago, Galvin sued Goldstein for providing information about Bulldog to a non-accredited investor, and ordered the hedge fund to pay a $25,000 fine. But Goldstein is not one to take such an affront lying down, and appealed. He said he plans to do so again.
“The ruling is wrong and we are going to appeal it,” Goldstein told Reuters. “Apparently, if you live in Massachusetts you have to be rich to read truthful material on a hedge fund Web site.”
“They are essentially saying that you can’t get a brochure for a Rolls Royce because you can’t afford the car, and that is not right,” he added. Bulldog has a $500,000 minimum investment requirement.