How Profitable Are High-Frequency Trading Strategies?

Oct 2 2009 | 9:25am ET

By Irene Aldridge -- High-frequency trading has been taking Wall Street by storm.  While no institution thoroughly tracks the performance of high-frequency funds, colloquial evidence suggests that the majority of high-frequency managers delivered positive returns in 2008, while 70% of low-frequency practitioners lost money, according to The New York Times.  

The discourse on the profitability of high-frequency trading strategies always runs into the question of availability of performance data on returns realized at different frequencies.  Hard data on performance of high-frequency strategies is indeed hard to find.  Hedge funds successfully running high-frequency strategies tend to shun the public limelight.  Others produce data from questionable sources.

Yet, performance at different frequencies can be compared using publicly available data by estimating the maximum potential profitability.  Profitability of trading strategies is often measured by Sharpe ratios, a risk-adjusted return metric first proposed by a Nobel Prize winner, William Sharpe.  A Sharpe ratio measures return per unit of risk; a Sharpe ratio of 2 means that the average annualized return on the strategy twice exceeds the annualized standard deviation of strategy returns: if the annualized return of a strategy is 12%, the standard deviation of returns is 6%.  The Sharpe ratio further implies the distribution of returns: statistically, in 95% of cases, the annual returns are likely stay within 2 standard deviations from the average.  In other words, in any given year, the strategy of Sharpe ratio of 2 and annualized return of 12% is expected to generate returns from 0% to 24% with 95% statistical confidence, or 95% of time.

The maximum possible Sharpe ratio for a given trading frequency is computed as a sample period’s average range (High – Low) divided by the sample period’s standard deviation of the range, adjusted by square root of the number of observations in a year.  Note that high-frequency strategies normally do not carry overnight positions, and, therefore, do not incur the overnight carry cost often proxied by the risk-free rate in Sharpe ratios of longer-term investments.

The table below compares the maximum Sharpe Ratios that could be attained at 10-second, 1-minute, 10-minute, 1-hour and 1-day frequencies in EUR/USD.  The results are computed ex-post with perfect 20/20 hindsight on the data for 30 trading days from February 9, 2009 through March 22, 2009.  The return is calculated as the maximum return attainable during the observation period within each interval at different frequencies.  Thus, the average 10-second return is calculated as the average of ranges (high-low) of EUR/USD prices in all 10-second intervals from  February 9, 2009 through March 22, 2009.  The standard deviation is then calculated as the standard deviation of all price ranges at a given frequency within the sample. 

Time Period

Average Max. Gain (Range) per Period Range Standard Deviation per Period Number of observations in the sample period Maximum Annualized Sharpe Ratio
10 seconds 0.04% 0.01% 2,592,000 5879.8
1 minute 0.06% 0.02% 43,200 1860.1
10 minutes 0.12% 0.09% 4,320 246.4
1 hour 0.30% 0.19% 720 122.13
1 day 1.79% 0.76% 30 37.3

As the table above shows, the maximum profitability of trading strategies measured using Sharpe ratios increases with increases in trading frequencies.  From  February 9, 2009 through March 22, 2009, the maximum possible annualized Sharpe ratio for EUR/USD trading strategies with daily position rebalancing was 37.3, while EUR/USD trading strategies that held positions for 10 seconds could potentially score Sharpe ratios well over 5,000 (five thousand) mark. 

In practice, well-designed and implemented strategies trading at the highest frequencies tend to produce double-digit Sharpe ratios.  Real-life Sharpe ratios for well-executed daily strategies tend to fall in the 1-2 range. 

Irene Aldridge is Managing Partner at Able Alpha Trading, Ltd., a proprietary high-frequency trading firm.  Ms. Aldridge’s new book, “High-Frequency Trading: A Practical Guide to Algorithmic Strategies and Trading Systems” is available for pre-order on Amazon.com.  Ms. Aldridge can be reached at ialdridge@ablealpha.com.  


In Depth

Q&A: Quad Advisors’ Borish Is Looking For Real Traders, Not Index Huggers

Aug 20 2014 | 1:43pm ET

Peter Borish, who served as founding partner and director of research at Tudor Investment...

Lifestyle

Viking Manager In Rent Dispute

Aug 11 2014 | 4:14am ET

A hedge fund manager is demanding most of his money back from his former landlord...

Guest Contributor

Majority Of Inflows Go To Brand Name Hedge Funds

Aug 12 2014 | 9:00am ET

Since the market correction of 2008, a vast majority of hedge fund net asset flows...

 

Editor's Note

 

Futures Magazine

PREVIEW July/August 2014 Cover

Inside Futures' 500th Issue

The July/August 2014 issue is our largest in years—filled with the best trading strategies and stories from 43 years of being the primary publication for commodity, stock, options and forex traders.

The Alpha Pages

TAP July/August 2014 Cover

Real talk on alternative investments, business & finance

The Alpha Pages Editor's Note