Nicholson Guilty Plea In Question After E-Mail Snafu

Oct 23 2009 | 3:14am ET

Accused hedge fund fraudster James Nicholson may plead guilty to charges that he ripped investors off to the tune of $160 million, apologetic prosecutors said this week.

The U.S. Attorney’s Office in Manhattan sent an e-mail to victims of Nicholson’s alleged Ponzi scheme on Tuesday, indicating that Nicholson would change his plea to guilty at a hearing yesterday, the Bergen (N.J.) Record reported. That didn’t happen, and the prosecutor’s office on Tuesday quickly apologized for the mistake.

A spokesman for the U.S. attorney’s office told the Record that the e-mail was sent in error and incorrectly stated that yesterday’s hearing would be for Nicholson to change his plea. Instead, the court date was a status conference, which was itself rescheduled for next week. The judge in the case was expected to set a trial schedule at the conference.

The government did not say whether Nicholson would change his plea on securities fraud, investment adviser fraud and mail fraud charges in the future, and his lawyer told the Record, “I’m not taking a plea Thursday, that’s for sure—not as of now.”

“It is a possibility, but as of now there’s no agreement in place,” Erika Edwards said.

Nicholson has been charged with defrauding some 370 investors in his Pearl River, N.Y.-based hedge fund, Westgate Capital Management. According to the SEC complaint, at least one Westgate fund claimed positive returns in 98 of 99 consecutive months. Nicholson allegedly created a fictitious accounting firm and providing some of his investors with bogus audited financial statements. He apparently concocted this imposter firm under the name of an actual accountant while using his own telephone number and driver's license to set up a “virtual office.”

By late 2008, the Nicholson’s funds had sustained such losses that he could no longer honor redemption requests and hid his losses from investors with bogus sales brochures. He also closed one fund that was heavily invested in Lehman Brothers and folded its assets into another fund. In addition, he issued bad checks to some investors seeking to cash out, and ultimately suspended all investor redemptions due to what he called investors' “irrational behavior.”

If convicted, Nicholson faces up to 65 years in prison.


In Depth

Steinbrugge: Will Hedge Funds Help or Hurt During the Next Market Correction?

Sep 7 2016 | 11:55pm ET

Most investors have become accustomed to quick rebounds when markets correct, but...

Lifestyle

Quattrex Sports AG Debuts Soccer-Focused UCITS Fund

Sep 9 2016 | 9:54pm ET

Innovative alternative investment company Quattrex Sports has unveiled a new UCITS...

Guest Contributor

Malik: The Ever-Changing Middle Market and The Entering Class of 2016

Sep 2 2016 | 5:01pm ET

Deal sourcing and origination is only going to get more competitive given current...